The Wall Street Journal article: Debtor’s Dilemma: Pay the Mortgage or Walk Away takes a look at under-water borrowers who live in states like California and Arizona where laws generally prohibit lenders from pursuing other assets of mortgage borrowers who strategically default on their loans (stop paying the mortgage even when they can afford to).

In Mesa, another suburb of Phoenix, low prices are helping to draw buyers who may walk away from other homes. Christina Delapp bought a house out of foreclosure in July for $49,000 in cash. She says she will stop paying the mortgage on another home she still owns in Tempe if she can’t sell in the next few months for more than the $312,000 that she owes.

Ms. Delapp, who has been jobless for 18 months, says that the new home is part of her survival strategy. “I feel very fortunate,” she says. “Regardless of what happens to my credit, we’ve managed to put together the best safety plan that I possibly could.”

Mr. Figg says that deciding to default on his loan was “the toughest decision I ever made.” He worried that if he ever loses his job he would be marooned in a home that he couldn’t sell for enough to pay off his loan, limiting his ability to find work in other parts of the country: “I couldn’t move up. I couldn’t move down. I couldn’t move out of the city. It was a very claustrophobic situation.”

By moving to an apartment, Mr. Figg expects to lower his costs by about $700 a month. He plans to put that into his savings account and says he is willing to rent for the next five years or so.

Lenders are guilty of having “manipulated” the housing market during the boom by accepting dubious appraisals, Mr. Figg says. “When I weighed everything,” he says, “I was able to sleep at night.”

Similar Posts:

Share